fbpx

FAIRNESS OF “FAIR MARKET VALUE”

Randy Gilbert, J.D.

Chief Happiness Officer

Florida’s Title Insurance Company

[email protected]

(954) 500-Title (8485)

 

The unfairness of “Fair Market Value” (FMV) is, well… who is to say what dollar amount is considered fair?  That was a question Virginia’s Supreme Court in Wilburn v. Mangano, 851 S.E. 2d 474 (Dec. 10, 2020) had to decide when determining whether a real estate contract was even valid when a buyer and seller agreed to sell property on a specified date using the ambiguous price term “at Fair Market Value,” without any more specificity as to how that FMV was to be determined.  That case is persuasive authority as to what may happen here in Florida.

FAIR MARKET VALUE

In Florida Real Estate Contracts should be “definite and certain as to essential terms.” According to Muñiz v. Crystal Lake Project LLC, 947 So.2d 464 (Fla. 3 DCA 2006)essential” terms include:

  • Description of the land;
  • Interest in the land being conveyed;
  • The Purchase price;
  • Time of Payment; and
  • Terms of Payment (e.g. financing terms)

Florida’s Supreme Court defines FMV using ”the classic formula that it is the amount a purchaser willing but not obliged to buy, would pay to one willing but not obliged to sell.” Walter v. Schuler, 176 So. 2d 81, 86 (Fla. 1965) (“ ’fair market value’ and ‘just valuation’ should be declared ‘legally synonymous’”).

Florida’s Department of Revenue defines FMV as, “the price at which a property, if offered for sale in the open market, with a reasonable time for the seller to find a purchaser, would transfer for cash or its equivalent, under prevailing market conditions between parties who have knowledge of the uses to which the property may be put, both seeking to maximize their gains and neither being in a position to take advantage of the exigencies of the other.”) F.A.C. 12D-1.002(2).

The IRS defines FMV as “the price at which the property would change hands between a buyer and a seller when both have reasonable knowledge of all the necessary facts and neither is being forced to buy or sell. If parties with adverse interests place a value on property in an arm’s-length transaction, that is strong evidence of fair market value. If there is a stated price for services, this price is treated as the fair market value unless there is evidence to the contrary.”  IRS  Pub. 544 Pg. 3 Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets

The Appraisal of Real Estate (14th  Edition, 2013)’s defines “Market Value”, as “The most probable price, as of a specified date, in cash, or in terms equivalent to cash, or in other precisely revealed terms, for which the specified property rights should sell after reasonable exposure in a competitive market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, with the buyer and seller each acting prudently, knowledgeably, and for self interest, and assuming that neither is under undue duress.”

The FDIC requires real estate appraisals for residential (if more than $400,000) and commercial (if more than $500,000) to be based on “Market Value.”  12 CFR §§ 323.3(a)(1),(13), 12 CFR §323.4(e).  “Market Value means the most probable price which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently and knowledgeably, and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby:

(1) Buyer and seller are typically motivated;

(2) Both parties are well informed or well advised, and acting in what they consider their own best interests;

(3) A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market;

(4) Payment is made in terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto; and

(5) The price represents the normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.”

Black’s Law Dictionary defines FMV, as “[t]he price that a seller is willing to accept and a buyer is willing to pay on the open market and in an arm’s-length transaction.” Black’s Law Dictionary 1865 (11th ed. 2019);

IS A PRICE STATING AT “FAIR MARKET VALUE” ENOUGH?

In Wilburn, a mother’s will and codicil (i.e. an amendment to a will) allowed her son to exercise an option to purchase the mother’s property by paying his two (2) sisters “an amount equal to the fair market value at the time of my death.”  The son served notice exercising his option, the sisters obtained two (2) appraisals of the FMV, with one valuing the property at $311,000 and the other at $270,000.  The sisters offered to settle in the middle at $290,500, but the brother refused.  The brother argued there was no enforceable contract because the price term was not sufficiently specific to establish mutual assent to the Property’s purchase price.  The trial court agreed and dismissed the case against the brother “because the method to compute fair market value was not provided.”  The Court observed that “An incomplete contract … is one from which one or more material terms have been entirely omitted” and that “A contract is uncertain if one of its material terms is expressed in so inexact, indefinite, or obscure language that the intent of the parties cannot be sufficiently ascertained to enable the court to carry it into effect.”  “Price is a material term, and it must be either “fixed by the agreement itself” or the agreement must provide a mode “for ascertaining it with certainty,” in order for a court to enforce….”

The Court noted that “There is no single, fixed approach to determine fair market value, as applied by appraisers or Virginia courts.”  “To determine a property’s fair market value, Virginia courts recognize many valuation approaches, such as the cost approach, income approach, sales approach, development cost analysis, and comparable sales approach.”

Valuation methods.    Appraisers can approach valuation using a: cost approach (how much will it cost to reproduce or create a comparable); income approach (how much income is anticipated); or sales comparisons approach  (how much are similar properties in relevant marketplace)[1]

The Court went on to state, “Each of these approaches utilizes different characteristics of a property to estimate fair market value, and each analyzes different elements of the property [as] likely [to] affect the price a potential buyer would be willing to pay for the property on the open market.”  Absent a more precise specification … regarding the particular approach to be applied to determine the Property’s fair market value as of Jeanne’s death, the codicil does not provide the price of the Property, or a means of ascertaining the price with certainty, without subsequent agreement between the parties. By its very nature, what is meant by the term fair market value—what a buyer is willing to accept and what a seller is willing to pay for something on a given day—cannot be known with certainty absent a more specific means for determining it being provided in the codicil. In this instance, the language in the codicil lacks the precision required to produce a ‘certainty’ as to price, which would allow a court to equitably compel a party to specifically perform a contract for the purchase of real property.”

 

Lesson to be learned.  If a buyer and seller are going to agree to price property at “FMV” then they may be well advised to come up with a method of making the price much more certain and definite.  In an effort to do so, I have seen parties agree to be bound by a certain appraiser, or by someone neutral who will determine an amount which everyone will be bound.   Either way seek advice.

 

DISCLAIMER:  Topics discussed are general concepts, not intended to constitute legal advice, accuracy, nor completeness, and may not be relied upon as such; consult an attorney or accountant.  The author is neither an attorney nor an accountant.  FTIC is a national award winning title insurance company known for its white glove customer service and “No Junk Fee Guarantee.” ®

 

[1] See, Appraisal Institute, Understanding Appraisals, The appraiser estimates the degree of similarity or difference between the subject property and the comparable sales by considering various elements of comparison:

  • Real property rights conveyed
  • Financing terms
  • Conditions of sale
  • Expenditures made immediately

after purchase

  • Market conditions
  • Location
  • Physical characteristics
  • Economic characteristics
  • Use/zoning
  • Non-realty components of value

You May Also Like
Don’t Wait, Check Your Eligibility For Senior and Caregiver Supportive Services

Boris AnocetoCase Management and Customer Experience DirectorUnited HomeCare®(305) 716-0710unitedhomecare.com Do you know if you are eligible for Florida’s Older Americans Act Title III B Federal funds for supportive services? The good news is you might be if you are age 60 or older or a caregiver to a senior. OAA Funds are allocated to your

Read More
Boris Anoceto
Navigating Crisis Communications Like a Pro: Lessons From Ted Lasso

Julie TalenfeldPresident of BoardroomPR1776 N. Pine Island Road, Suite 320Fort Lauderdale, FL [email protected] If you’ve ever been in the thick of a crisis at work, you know that it can feel like you’ll never quite be able to get out! But what if you could turn to an unlikely source for guidance? Enter Ted Lasso,

Read More
Julie Talenfeld
You Saved My Marriage!

Carolyn Zaumeyer Nurse Practitioner LowTE Florida 4540 N. Federal Highway Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.791.4498 lowteflorida.com I can’t tell you how many times I have heard this – it is music to my ears. I often think about how unfair it can be that people experience significant changes as their hormone levels naturally decline with

Read More
Carolyn z
Blogging: The Indispensable Tool for Modern Marketing

Julie TalenfeldPresident of BoardroomPR1776 N. Pine Island Road, Suite 320Fort Lauderdale, FL [email protected] Since the early days of the internet, blogging has completely transformed from a platform for sharing personal stories into a powerful business tool. It’s not just important—it’s essential for any comprehensive marketing strategy. Here, I’ll break down why blogging has become a

Read More
Julie Talenfeld
Other Posts
Chromium: A Possible Game Changer For Diabetics

Simone De Oliveira, RD, LDN Nutrition Program Director United HomeCare® 305.716.0710 unitedhomecare.com Chromium found in “Brewer’s Yeast” has repeatedly been linked to improved A1c levels. Despite the progress in modern medicine, diabetes continues to be a significant public health issue, with many individuals struggling to maintain healthy blood glucose levels with existing treatments. The World

Read More
Simone De Oliveira
Hormones Are Safe For Menopausal Women!

Carolyn Zaumeyer Nurse Practitioner LowTE Florida 4540 N. Federal Highway Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.791.4498 lowteflorida.com Imagine my joy as I heard this on the national news morning shows! FINALLY! The world is catching on! But as I watched the segments, I learned they are just re-analyzing the Women’s Health Initiative study data from 2002

Read More
Carolyn z
Caring for the Caregiver: A Need for Family Commitment

Guadalupe Rodriguez, MSW-LCSW, MPHCounseling ManagerUnited HomeCaree®305.716.0710unitedhomecare.com According to the Population Reference Bureau, the number of Americans ages 65 and older is projected to increase from 58 million in 2022 to 82 million by 2050 (a 47% increase). The CDC warns us that as the population ages and disability worsens, it is critical to understand the

Read More
Guadalupe Rodriguez
What You Don’t Know About Hormone Pellets

Carolyn Zaumeyer Nurse Practitioner LowTE Florida 4540 N. Federal Highway Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.791.4498 lowteflorida.com There is so much misinformation around hormone therapy which unfortunately creates unnecessary fear. Many patients have been told hormones are bad and can cause cancer, heart disease, or blood clots, which is just not true. The good news is

Read More
Carolyn z