fbpx

The SEC vs. Realtors

Randy Gilbert, J.D.

Chief Happiness Officer

Florida’s Title Insurance Company

[email protected]

(954) 500-Title (8485)

THE SEC vs. REALTORS   

Watch What You Promise Buyers.   In October 2022, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) filed a multi-count Federal lawsuit against a Florida real estate agent and his real estate companies. The SEC sought a permanent injunction against the Realtor from practicing real estate, disgorgement of all funds as ill-gotten gains, interest, and civil penalties, due to the real estate agent’s alleged violation of Sections §5(a) [Selling a Security without an approved prospectus], §5(c) [Selling unregistered securities], §17(a)(1) [Offering a security as an artifice/scheme to defraud], §17(a)(2) [Offering a security with untrue statements or omissions], §17(a)(3) [engage in fraud or deceit] of the Federal Securities Act, and §10(b) [use manipulative or deceptive devices], §10b-5(a) [employ device/scheme/defraud], §10b-5(c) [engage in fraud/deceit], §15(a)(1) [Failing to registered as a national securities broker] of the Federal Exchange Act.1  

What did the Realtor do?  The SEC accused the realtor of giving investors: (1) Assurances their investments would be successful; (2) An “Attestation of Rent” guaranteeing investors a specified monthly rental income; (3) False promises how their funds would be used, to wit: to repair, renovate, and then lease properties, but the funds were not used for that purpose; (4) Marketing brochures with pictures, descriptions and addresses of the properties, amount of rent and taxes, the property management fee, and the amount of expected monthly profits; and (5) An opportunity to invest in an enterprise which would generate investment returns 

“Securities” include more than you think.  So what’s wrong with promising a buyer a return on their investment?  Well, you may be surprised to learn that although the term “Securities” is generally thought of as traditional investments like stocks and bonds; “securities” also includes the much broader and more encompassing term “Investment Contracts.”  Both the SEC and the federal courts frequently use the “investment contract” analysis to determine whether business offerings or arrangements qualify as a “security,” which therefore would be under their jurisdiction and subject to federal securities laws.  In fact, for well over half a century, “investment contracts” have been the critical vehicle used by the SEC to bring a host of investments into the traditional definition of a security.2 

Howey analysis of “Investment Contracts.”  The U.S. Supreme Court’s Howey case and subsequent cases have found that an investment contract exists when: (1) a person invests money; (2) in a common enterprise; (3) with a reasonable expectation of profits; (4) to be derived from the efforts of others.3  The so-called “Howey?test” applies to any contract, scheme, or transaction, regardless of whether it has any of the characteristics of typical securities.4? The focus of the?Howey?analysis is not only on the form and terms of the instrument itself but also on the circumstances surrounding the investment and the manner in which it is offered, sold, or resold.? Therefore, persons and entities engaged in the marketing, offering, selling, reselling, or distribution of any investment will need to analyze the offering to determine whether the federal securities laws apply. 

So what if what I am offering is a security?  The SEC’s goal is to provide investors with enough information to allow investors to make informed investment decisions.? Therefore, the federal securities laws require all offers and sales of securities, to either be registered under the SEC’s provisions or to qualify for an exemption from registration.? The registration provisions are stringent, require persons to disclose certain information to investors, and which must be both complete and not materially misleading.5??Therefore, in hindsight, it probably would have been advisable for the Realtor to not have made such bold promises that the buyers/investors were guaranteed any type of investment return and should conduct their own due diligence.   

DISCLAIMER:? Topics discussed are general concepts, not intended to constitute legal advice, accuracy, nor completeness, and may not be relied upon as such; consult an attorney or accountant.  The author Randy Gilbert, J.D. is neither an attorney nor an accountant. ?FTIC is a national award winning title insurance company known for its white glove customer service and “No Junk Fee Guarantee.”  

 

 

You May Also Like

Vegetable A’B’C’s Asparagus

Lenore Nolan-Ryan Lenore Nolan Ryan Catering & Cooking School Galt Ocean Plaza 3311 North Ocean Blvd, Ft Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.491.2340 lenorenolanryan.com Tips of asparagus, green, white or purple, of which purple has a sweeter flavor, bid the sun hello as they individually peek through their mineral soil. Asparagus can grow up to half an

Honoring Champions of Aging

Michelle Barton-King, Esq., Barton King Law, P.A. Secretary of the Board United HomeCare 305.716.0710 or visit unitedhomecare.com On May 11, 2023, United HomeCare® will proudly present the Claude Pepper Awards in memory of the late Senator Claude Pepper, a beloved public servant who tirelessly championed causes on behalf of the elderly and is credited with giving

Antidepressants For Hot Flashes?

Carolyn Zaumeyer Nurse Practitioner LowTE Florida 4540 N. Federal Highway Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.791.4498 LowTEFlorida.com Seriously??? Many traditional doctors (that don’t really understand Bio-Identical Hormones) are prescribing antidepressants for menopausal hot flashes. Some potential side effects of antidepressants include: Anxiety, Blurred vision, Constipation, Dizziness, Dry mouth, Fatigue, Feeling numb, Insomnia, Nausea, & Sexual side

Cook Together! Stay Together!

Lenore Nolan-Ryan Lenore Nolan Ryan Catering & Cooking School Galt Ocean Plaza 3311 North Ocean Blvd, Ft Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.491.2340 lenorenolanryan.com Why do I love teaching cooking classes? It isn’t just about the cooking. It’s about you. It’s an evolving experience between you and the ingredients, the equipment, and the interaction with your friends,

Other Posts

How Long Does Menopause Last?

Carolyn Zaumeyer Nurse Practitioner LowTE Florida 4540 N. Federal Highway Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.791.4498 LowTEFlorida.com I am asked this all the time ~ The interesting answer is (as you probably guessed) it is different for everyone. Some women breeze through menopause without a hot flash or any of the other obvious symptoms. But for

Carolyn Zaumeyer
The Art of Entertaining

Lenore Nolan-Ryan Lenore Nolan Ryan Catering & Cooking School Galt Ocean Plaza 3311 North Ocean Blvd, Ft Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.491.2340 lenorenolanryan.com When I am asked the question “how do you throw a great party?” It is without hesitation I say, “pick a theme!” Hosting a gathering small or large, in your backyard, living room,

Lenore Ryan
Valentine’s Day: A Catered Affair

Lenore Nolan-Ryan Lenore Nolan Ryan Catering & Cooking School Galt Ocean Plaza 3311 North Ocean Blvd, Ft Lauderdale, FL 33308 954.491.2340 lenorenolanryan.com Valentine’s Day is celebrated every year on February 14 and is considered the most romantic holiday of the year. The holiday’s roots are ancient and related to a Christian martyr, Saint Valentine of

Lenore Ryan
Crypto-Backed Mortgages

Randy Gilbert, J.D. Chief Happiness Officer Florida’s Title Insurance Company [email protected] (954) 500-Title (8485)  CRYPTO-BACKED MORTGAGES  In this article, I interviewed crypto-lender Milo, because it is locally headquartered in Miami, was a featured speaker at the Miami Association of Realtors’ 2022 Global Congress at the Biltmore Hotel in Coral Gables last month, closed over $100

Randy Gilbert